CAROME. Calomy 液態眼線筆 自然棕 防水 by 達雷諾加蕾明美

I've tried so many brown eyeliners that end up looking gray or harsh, but this one's really that natural light brown I was after. The film formula keeps it on through my whole workday, even when I accidentally rub my eye, and it doesn't smudge at all. It's become my go-to for a clean, soft line that

Used it through a rainy commute and it didn’t budge — the film formula really holds up against rubbing too. The natural brown shade gives a soft, clean line that’s easier to wear than black. My only tiny gripe is the brush takes a couple tries to get the right pressure, but once you do, it’s a solid

I was honestly skeptical about a brown eyeliner that's waterproof, but this one holds up even after a long sweaty day. The natural brown shade is surprisingly bright and gives a clean, subtle look without smudging. The formula doesn't flake or fade, and it's been perfect for my allergy-prone eyes.